MERV 8 vs Merv 11 vs Merv 13: Which is Best?

May 16, 2024
A homeowner installing a new air filter for their HVAC system.

As a homeowner, you know your HVAC system needs air filters, but did you know there are different ratings, including MERV 8, 11, and 13? The different filter ratings affect the air quality in your home and could affect how you and your household members feel.

A good air filter is the first line of defense against air pollution, but choosing the wrong air filter has the potential to put too much pressure on your system.

According to the American Lung Association, indoor air can be as much as 100 times more polluted than outdoor air. This can cause problems for anyone, not to mention those who suffer from allergies or asthma. 

However, by choosing the right air filter, you can improve the air your family members breathe and decrease the risk of respiratory issues. The more filtered your air is, the better it is for your health

Understanding the difference between MERV 8, MERV 11, and MERV 13 air filters and how they affect your family and HVAC system are the key to choosing the best filters.

What is a MERV rating?

MERV stands for Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value. It rates a filter’s ability to capture particles, such as dust, pet dander, viruses, and mold. The rating comes from the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air Conditioning Engineers and can help you choose the right filter for your home.

The MERV rating ranges from 1 – 16 and the higher the number, the smaller the microns the filters can capture. MERV ratings are based on a filter’s ability to capture microns measuring 0.3 to 10 microns. The smaller the microns a filter can capture, the cleaner the air in the house.

To help put the size into perspective, a piece of human hair is 100 microns, as is the thickness of a standard piece of paper. At half that size, we cannot see the pollutant with the naked eye, and a dust mite can measure just 10 microns, but most are five or less.

Basic air filters can capture large particles (up to 10 microns), but if you have highly sensitive household members, choosing an air filter with better capturing abilities may be necessary for their overall health.

The average homeowner uses air filters with an 8 MERV rating. However, households with highly sensitive individuals with allergies or asthma may opt for higher MERV ratings as high as 13.

Overview of MERV 8 Filters

MERV 8 filters are one of the most common air filters homeowners choose. While a common choice, they have advantages and disadvantages to understand.

Definitions and Characteristics

According to the EPA, a MERV 8 filter can capture up to 70% of microns measuring 3.0 – 10.0 microns and 20% measuring 1.0 – 3.0. This is usually sufficient for a standard home with no concerns about asthma or allergies.

Because it cannot filter microns smaller than 1.0 and only captures 20% of those between 1.0 and 3.0, many standard pollutants, including pet dander and airborne bacteria, can pass through the filter. This isn’t an issue for most people, but allergy sufferers or those with chronic health conditions may need something better.

Advantages

  • Captures most standard household pollutants, including dust, pollen, and pet hair
  • Captures a majority of large particles
  • Priced well

Limitations

  • May not be strong enough for people with allergies
  • Lets through things like pet dander and certain bacteria

Overview of MERV 11 Filters

MERV 8 filters are the most basic filter and the one many homeowners choose. They are the safest for most HVAC systems, but they may let harmful particles through, which could bother sensitive individuals. MERV 11 filters are a step up from MERV 8, capturing more large particles and helping capture smaller particles.

Definitions and Characteristics

MERV 11 filters are a step up from MERV 8 filters, capturing an even larger number of pollutants. MERV 11 filters capture up to 85% of 3.0 – 10.0 microns, 65% of 1.0 – 3.0 microns and 20% of 0.30% – 1.0 microns. So they capture much smaller particles than MERV 8 and a larger number of standard particles larger than 3.0 microns.

MERV 11 filters are common for pet owners as they are more likely to capture pet hair and some pet dander.

Advantages

  • May eliminate smaller dust and bacteria particles
  • Helps capture sneeze bacteria
  • Can be good for people with allergies

Limitations

  • Restricts the airflow, which can make the HVAC system work harder
  • Can be too much filtration for households without pets or allergy issues

Overview of MERV 13 Filters

MERV 13 filters are the highest most HVAC systems can go, and they should be used only when the manufacturer’s directions specifically state that they are acceptable.

Definitions and Characteristics

According to the EPA, MERV 13 filters capture 90% of 3.0 – 10.0 microns, 85% of 1.0 – 3.0 microns, and 50% of 0.3 – 1.0 microns. Thus, they provide the best protection against airborne bacteria and viruses.

They are recommended for families with newborn babies, household members who smoke, or household members with severe allergies or chronic health conditions.

Advantages

  • Can provide the cleanest environment for at-risk individuals
  • May catch microscopic allergens
  • Captures up to 90% of large particles

Limitations

  • If used against the manufacturer’s suggestion, it could cause premature HVAC system failure
  • Higher cost than MERV 8 or MERV 11 filters

Comparison Between MERV 8, 11, and 13 Filters

Consider what you’re trying to filter when choosing between MERV 8 vs MERV 11 and MERV 13. The higher the MERV rating, the smaller the particles the filter can capture. 

However, you should only choose the MERV rating that captures the particles most bothersome for your household members, opting for MERV 8 if you don’t have any special concerns.

If you choose a higher MERV rating, be sure to change your filter more frequently. The more particles a filter captures, the less airflow it allows. 

The more you restrict your airflow, the more damage you can do to your HVAC system. Regularly changing your filters and getting an HVAC inspection ensures the health of your system.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between MERV Ratings

When choosing the best MERV rating for your home, consider the following factors.

Specific air quality concerns

First, determine if any household members have special concerns, such as allergies, or chronic respiratory issues, such as COPD, RSV, or asthma. If you have someone highly allergic or with serious breathing concerns, choosing an air filter with a higher MERV rating could help them breathe better.

HVAC system compatibility

Always check with your manufacturer’s recommendations when choosing a MERV rating. The ASHRAE currently recommends using a MERV rating of 13 whenever possible because it can capture the smallest particles, including viruses. 

However, they also state that if your system cannot handle MERV 13, you should choose a filter with the highest MERV rating the manufacturer suggests.

Budget considerations

The higher a filter’s MERV rating, the more expensive it is. While costs vary wildly from retailer to retailer, on average, expect to pay $10 – $100 for MERV 8, $10 to $200 for MERV 11, and $20 – $200 for MERV 13.

Conclusion

Knowing the highest MERV rating your HVAC system can handle is important, as is understanding the frequency you must change it. The more pollutants you can keep out of your home, the cleaner air you’ll breathe. 

However, when comparing MERV 8 vs MERV 11 or 13, the airflow restriction increases the higher the MERV rating. It’s best to consult with an HVAC professional to determine which MERV rating is best for your system to ensure clean air and good health for your HVAC system.

FAQs

Is MERV 13 too high for home?

MERV 13 is the highest rating for home use, but it’s not too high if your HVAC system allows it. After COVID-19, this was the filter rating the ASHRAE recommended for all homes, regardless of whether any household member had allergies or breathing issues.

However, they put more strain on the HVAC system, so it’s important to change them regularly and inspect your system frequently.

Is MERV 11 too restrictive?

MERV 11 filters are more restrictive than MERV 8 but not too restrictive for most units. Read your manufacturer’s instructions to ensure your system can withstand a MERV 11 rating, and if so, be sure to change it regularly. Like MERV 13, MERV 11 filters can decrease airflow and capture small particles that could pollute indoor air.

Does MERV 8 restrict airflow?

MERV 8 filters don’t restrict airflow as much as MERV 11 and MERV 13 filters. However, they do capture particles measuring 1.0 – 10.0 microns. They are the best at capturing particles greater than 3.0 microns, but they catch about 20% of smaller particles, too.

Check Out Additional HVAC Resources

Sources